Replay value in games comes in all shapes and sizes. For the Silent Hill series, Konami likes to add a lot of endings to their games. Silent Hill 2, for example, has six endings in the original game which Bloober Team kept in the remake albeit tweaked a bit. They also added two new endings for players to enjoy.

There are a total of six different weapons that players can find in the town which cannot be obtained before reaching a certain point in the story. Silent Hill 2 Remake weapon placement is spaced out, giving players ample time to stick with a weapon before experimenting with a new one against the town's monstrosities.