"We only wanted the people we have had a consistent relationship with since the show," Heringer tells PEOPLE. "So my best friend Chelsea [Vaughn], who lives in New York. Serena [C

Abigail Heringer and Noah Erb have cemented themselves as yet another Bachelor in Paradise success story. The couple tied the knot at the Philbrook Museum of Art in Tulsa, Oklahoma, the couple confirmed on social media.

Bachelor in Paradise alums Abigail Heringer, a deaf advocate and influencer, and Noah Erb, an ICU nurse, real estate investor, and home improvement expert, always knew their wedding would prioritize their guests—and time spent with them—over tradition.